The Scorpions struggled from the beginning and never made the semi finals once in either the BRL 1st Grade or the Queensland Cup. Their most successful seasons were 1999 & 2000 in which the club finished 7th out of 12 teams. They made the Brisbane A Grade grand final in 2000 but lost the game 28-10 to the Easts Tigers.
Logan's fortunes declined in 2001 and 2002. In their final year they failed to win a single game in either the Queensland Cup or Brisbane A Grade. At the completion of that season the football and leagues clubs were wound up, and the Souths Logan Magpies were formed.