After graduation, Tsarfin worked briefly as an assistant editor at the comic book publisher Marvel Comics. She then returned to High Times and became its managing editor. From 2001 to 2005, she served as managing editor of the hip-hop magazine XXL. In June 2005, she was named managing editor of satiric humor magazine CRACKED. She left that position in March 2006 to return to High Times. In January 2007, she became managing editor of the Atlanta, Georgia-based Web site at SuperDeluxe.com, Turner Broadcasting's online comedy network.